Zcash Community Grants offered to surrender roughly $124 million in current reserves and future token emissions on Thursday, attempting to defuse an escalating community dispute over whether the development fund wields too much capital without sufficient oversight.
Under the preliminary framework proposed on the Zcash forum, the grant organization plans to transfer 36,200 ZEC, worth approximately $46 million, from its current 91,500 ZEC balance into the Network Sustainability Mechanism (NSM). The NSM functions as an on-chain reserve that recycles tokens back into future block subsidies for miners. The transfer would leave the committee with roughly 55,200 ZEC in direct reserves, valued at around $70 million.
Extending the Runway While Trimming Future Inflows
Beyond the immediate treasury cut, the committee offered to forfeit approximately 62,000 ZEC ($78.5 million) from future block reward distributions. In exchange, ZCG wants to stretch out its remaining funding schedule.
Under current protocol parameters, the organization receives an automatic allocation that runs through 2028. The new proposal would instead taper those payments at reduced rates until the 2032 halving, ultimately redirecting a combined 98,000 ZEC back to the mining ecosystem across both balance sheet cuts and forgone issuance. ZCG indicated that a formalized proposal will be submitted for community review following initial feedback.
The compromise comes on the heels of a more aggressive model floated by Zcash co-founder Sean Bowe, who previously advocated cutting off ZCG’s automatic 8% cut of newly minted ZEC entirely. Bowe’s setup would divert that entire stream to the NSM while leaving the existing grant treasury intact, effectively forcing the organization to operate solely on its accumulated capital.
Critics Push for Holder Oversight
The concession failed to satisfy prominent industry voices who argue the fundamental issue is governance structure rather than token math.
Helius chief executive Mert Mumtaz criticized the compromise on X, calling the proposal “nowhere near good enough.” Mumtaz argued that the retained treasury balance remains excessively large, maintaining that capital distribution must answer directly to ZEC holders rather than a small committee.
The dispute quickly turned personal when Mumtaz pointed out that a committee member had unfollowed him on social media amid the debate. Gemini co-founder Tyler Winklevoss weighed in on the exchange, stating that such conduct raised doubts over whether the individual was qualified to oversee a fund managing more than $110 million.
The clash highlights ongoing friction across proof-of-work protocols over foundation funding models, where direct protocol subsidies often insulate grant distributors from the token holders who absorb the dilutive cost.




